Sunday 25 February 2018

Abstract on "The canon of Indian literature in English Translation"

Image result for translation

"The canon of Indian literature in English Translation"
Rinkal jani
(Student of Master of Arts, Sem-4)
Department of English,
Maharaja Krishnakumarsinghji, Bhavnagar University, Gujarat, India
Connect no; 8735860517

It is better to fail in originality than to succeed in imitation. - Herman Melville
 Translation in the Indian context was more of Trans-creation or retelling done by the translator in his/her style.one can translate one literature from one language to another, Apart from story A translator translates one culture, its sense into another. But sometimes during the process of translation there are some issues generating like Equivalence, originality, fidelity, etc. As historian Romila thapar notice that the retelling of the ancient text there where the concept of fidelity to the original was absent in India not only in India but in western also. This paper aims to find out the Problems during the translating the Indian ancient Sanskrit text “Abhigyanshakuntalam” by kalids , into English as well in Sanskrit by writers like Sir William Jones, sir monier Williams,Chandra Rajan and M R kale. Its aims to find the problem of Fidelity or equivalence with the use of Indian Aesthetic theory of Rasa, It’s also try to finds the issues in translation by applying the theory of translation of Sri Aurobindo.In Sanskrit the term is ‘anuvad’, meaning ‘to say after’ while in some other Indian languages the words are terms ‘bhashantar’ (change from one language to another), ‘roopantar’ (change from one code to another in terms of external form or language).In a way they reflect the issues in the translation field today in India. This research aims to analyzing questions like What is translation? Is it just changing from one language to another or a more radical alteration where the form itself is changed? In this context, how relevant are the concepts of fidelity to the SL? Today the debates in translation also center on the power dynamics between languages.Why is it that most Indian texts get translated into English and not other Indian languages? 


Paper on Film literature and culture"


 Film literature and culture

Presented by  Rinkal jani

                                            (Student of Master of Arts, Sem-3)

                                       Department of English,
                                     MK Bhavnagar University, Gujarat, India     
                                      E-mail: rinkaljani1807@gmail.com
                                                 Connect no; 8735860517 
             

Abstract:

 Sub: Films, literature  and Culture

Aims of presenting this paper

1   1)      Representation of society, culture, literature in film through language
2   2)      Breaking of gender stereotypes
Pursue a broadly inter disciplinary course of study focusing on the comparative analysis of film in its relationship to literature, society as well as culture and its aesthetic traditions. Film and literature are two mediums one literary the other performative. Which use language and image in order to capture the lived reality of cultural construct . Films are cultural artifacts created by specific cultures. Literature is considered as the mere reflection or mirror of the society, as well Films are also considered as visual X-ray image of the society. Indian film makers like satyajit ray, Mrinal sen,, shyam benegal, have seamlessly transformed the words on the dialogue on screen. This paper focus upon the adaptation of literature in Indian cinema and how literature is being visualize by film and its impact upon audience and literature readers. Indian filmmakers are always in search of to show some new story, new society, or its tradition and culture through the film. They are in search of presenting something new and different in film. Writers are trying to capturing   the issues are surrounding them, past- present socio-political issue  like Indian independent movement, or Indian emergency era, partition of Pakistan and India, or some social issues like child marriage system,  and all others. Cultural tradition like ‘street play” like “Bhavai”, “Akhyan” which are representing  Gujarati tradition. This paper  try to find out that through film how this tradition, or various socio-political issue is presented.
  How society and culture reflects in the film?

    As we know India is nation which has numerous varieties of culture and language. The prominent language in India besides English and Hindi are Bengali, Tamil, Telugu, Urdu, and Guajarati or many others. Language is a powerful tool in representing and structuring the world. Language is very essential source of society through which one community or society is built up. It also can help to construct identity of human, its stereotypes, identities and human relationship. Stereotypes like Gender inequality, marginalizes identity of women and third gender. In this context of Gender and inequality Language and hegemony is also important part to study here. Language is control by the power. Now a day these stereotypes are also on the way of changing.

What do we mean by “culture”?
     Culture is very vast term to define. When we talk about “culture” we often mean intellectual and creative products, including literature, music, drama, and painting. Another use of “culture” is to describe the beliefs and practices of another society, particularly where these are seen as closely linked with tradition or religion. But culture is more than that. Culture is part of the fabric of every society, including our own. It shapes “the way things are done” and our understanding of why this should be so. This more comprehensive approach is proposed in the definition of culture adopted at the World Conference on Cultural Policies (Mexico, 1982) and used in ongoing discussions on culture and development: “Culture… is… the whole complex of distinctive spiritual, material, intellectual and emotional features that characterize a society or a social group. It includes not only arts and letters, but also modes of life, the fundamental rights of the human being, value systems, traditions and beliefs.”

What do we mean by Indian culture?

 The culture of India is one of the oldest and unique. In India, there is amazing cultural diversity throughout the country. Indian culture is a composite mixture of varying styles and influences. 

Dr Raj Kumar has define the Indian culture in  his essay on “Indian Culture”, that Inadia’s culture has been enriched by successive waves of migration on which were absorbed into the indian way of life. It is this veriety which is a special hallmark of India. Its physical, religious and racial variety is an immense as it linguistic diversity. Underneath this diversity lies the continuity of  Indian civilization and social structure from the very earliest times until the present day. There is perhaps no phenomenon as complex as culture. In a manner of speaking, culture is everything in particular society. Indian culture is no easy composition of verifying styles and influences.
The word “Culture” has broad range of meaning or including the things for studies. It is depend upon us that how we looks at culture and what we consider or rather including in to the culture. It has not narrow space for definition. Culture is not only a matter of music, art, dance, and  cinema, for marriage customs, death rites, patterns of pilgrimage to holy elites, modes of raising children, treatments of elders, and innumerable other aspects of everyday life are stitched into the meaning of culture.
Apart from that, The concept of culture is very complicated, and the word has many meanings.[1] The word 'culture' is most commonly used in three ways.
·         Excellence of taste in the fine arts and humanities, also known as high culture.
·         An integrated pattern of human knowledgebelief, and behavior.
·         The outlook, attitudes, valuesmorals goals, and customs shared by a society.
On this ground of society or its behavior, belief we can include few more things that not only tradition and customs are culture but how society behaves with other human is also a part of culture. In Indian society there are so many positive- negative aspects we find like Gender stereotypes, Marginalization of two identity one is women and second is Third Gender, (LGBT) (Hijar,Kinner),lesbian relationship, cultural hegemony, Hybridity of culture, Male Dominance, hegemony of language, Identity crises, poverty, bloody partition of India-Pakistan, and etc. This all can also being a part of Indian culture, or part of Indian society.

  Literature and Indian culture

Image result for literature and indian cultureImage result for literature and indian culture

Literature is literary form and film is form of performance to represent culture. Its not easy to
Decide if film and literature represent the culture or film and literature creates such culture.
Drama was the form of literature and with the development of technology drama has been
turned in to film. But after seeing the popularity of film it has become separated field like
Literature . Film is not only for entertainment but it also represents culture of particular
Society .
There are different kinds of films which represent reality like third cinema, parallel cinema
etc. which suggest reality but they have different way of presentation. Literature and film are
always shaped by people and its depends on their attitude towards the society. Literature is
like water, Film plays the role of fire and culture is the earth for society. Deepa Mehta’s
trilogy of films- Earth, Water and Fire describe these three elements clearly. It represents
film, Literature and culture with the help of camera. Culture provides raw material for
literature and film.
Film and literature become successful when it can represent catharsis so that people can feel
such bond with the film and literature. Film adaption is like amalgamation of all these three
elements. With help of few film adaption we can understand it clearly. Beginning time of the
film shows that novel or any short stories were raw material for any of the film. It is a
continuous process and one cannot decide the beginning point of this cycle. Culture is
lifeblood to the literature.
Human behaviour, social norms and value made culture, Language made literature and
performance made film. Whenever one has tried to compare film and fiction they always
come to the conclusion that both are totally different form of the literature so they have their
own glory.
  
“Nothing is original. Steal from anywhere that resonates with inspiration or fuels your imagination.” – Jim Jarmusch.

Adapting a novel into a two-hour movie is a big challenge in itself as sometimes, accommodating the story to fit in the time length messes up the whole essence of the original art It is said that literature is Mirror or x-ray image of the society, whatever happens in the society it is captured by the writer of that present time. Literature is mere worded version of the any particular society. Some of Indian writer who very well depict the history of Indian culture,  in his/novel or any of the writing. The writer like R.k Narayan, Raja Rao, Mulkraj Anand, Rabindranath Tagore, Sarat Chandra chattopadhyay, Amrita pritam and like many other Indian others or writer who reflects the Indian way of living life, Indian society, regional life of Indian, poor or middle class people of India, Tagore who also recreates  the Bengal in his writing.

Global impact of Indian culture with India movie.


Image result for Global impact of Indian culture with India movie
  Image result for movies Culture and society has deeply influence over the indian cinema. Such as Satyajit ray’, Deepa Meheta, ketant Meheta they are very well re-present the indian culture or indian people’s way of living life on the cinema. They are given visual pictrues of indian different cultures like keten Meheta in his film ‘Mirch masala” very well depict the Guajarati culture, or their small business on chilli factory or Gujarati costumes, their customs everything is depicted very well. It is movie in which a female has to fight against the power oppressor, sonbai a female protagonist ,Male dominance over the village. Gujrati film “Bhavni Bhavai” , its represent the old ancient Guajarati culture of street play.

Literature and culture with Deepa meheta’s trilogy

Image result for Deepa meheta’s trilogy
    When we talk about Indian culture at that Deepa meheta’s trilogy of Fire,water and Earth is being prominent. Because this trilogy includes all the aspects of what we call culture as the way of living life of people and their tradition .  Manju Jadidka, who wrote about film that,Deepa Mehta is an acclaimed Indo-Canadian script writer and film director. She challenges conservative social mores and attempts to rewrite history, representing 'her' story instead of 'his'. Mehta has been a controversial figure ever since 1998 when her film Fire was banned in India for its explicit portrayal of lesbianism. Her next film Earth spoke of the Partition of India and how it affected the lives of women. With her third film Water, Mehta again ran into trouble with fundamentalists when she tried to focus on the shabby treatment meted out to widows by traditional Hindu society. Deepa Mehta's 'Elemental Trilogy' Fire, Earth and Water. Focusing on the film texts, it examines the silent spaces in-between the signifiers and tunes into the unheard voices that patriarchy has been deaf to. It also studies the impact of Mehta's work, critically analyzing the hostile reception accorded to her work, and the by-and-large-favorable response of the female section of the society. Contents: Desire in Another Language: The Politics of Fire Engendering History: 1947 Earth Abandoned by the Riverside: Water Beyond National Boundaries Deepa Mehta: On a Personal Note Bibliogra. Ms Mehta’s trilogy first explored the taboo of female homosexuality in Fire, The film raised issues such as homosexuality and feminism in the traditional backward thought of the Indian patriarchal society. This film was quite a shock to the Indian audiences and was widely opposed by various political parties and religious groups. But this film went on to receive the honor of the best film in many women international film festivals around the globe.
      then the taboo of religious extremism in Earth. Based on the novel, Cracking India by Bapsi Sidhwa, Earth depicts the plight of people during the time of India’s independence and partition in 1947. The film is from the point of view of a young Parsi girl, Lenny. Lenny is from a rich family, who hopes to remain neutral on the rising tensions between Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs. Shanta is a beautiful Hindu woman and Lenny’s ayah. Both Dil Navaz, the ice-candy wala and Hassan, the masseur are Muslims and in love with Shanta. All of them are in a unified group of people from various religions, most of whom are servants in Lenny’s house. But what happens when the ties of friendship are broken by war is brilliantly described in this film. This film is considered to be one of the best stories of deceit and betrayal. What does it feel to be rejected; both by your love and by your country are superbly shown in this film and that too, from the point of view of a little girl in Lahore. Now comes Water, The third and last in the elements trilogy, this film was the most successful one amongst the three. This film won enormous awards and is considered to be one of the most successful Hindi Films. The film asked the basic questions as to whether we should blindly follow the words of our ancient Vedas and Upanishads, according to which a widow were to always be chastised and be made felt guilty of their husbands’ death each and every second they live on this earth.
         Deepa Mehta herself admits that all these films were very difficult to be made, as all these films were highly controversial and faced oppositions from various political parties and religious groups. Water, for example had to be shot in Sri Lanka and that too under the name, River Moon, due to widespread demonstrations against the film in India. which attacks the taboo of social humiliation of women. Let’s hope that Ms Mehta’s movies make a difference.

Gender bias language in Film

Image result for Gender bias in Film
         Gender stereotypes are the mind sets of the society practiced years after years. Men and women are assigned gender roles according to these already set patterns. As a result of practicing these gender stereotypes, women are assigned weaker position as compared to men. Indian society is highly patriarchal society, in which men dominance over women, and also dominance over third gender. Gender stereotype are not only for girls or women but also is about third gender community who has also as marginalized as women. There many Bollywood movie we can see that there is many dialogue which indicates this bias language. For example, Here are some quotes from famous films which might have been declared blockbusters, but certain dialogues or lyrics definitely proved that Bollywood has always reinforced gender stereotypes in India.
  Famous dialogue from film “Mard” in which  “Mard ko kabhi dard nahi hota”, its indicates the strength of m (kumar) (meheta) (k. meheta)ale so what about female? Ther is another song lyrics from “Khandan” movie “Tum hi meri pooja, tumhi mera mandir,tumhi meri pooja” its indicates the subjugation of female in front of male. As well a dialogue from movie “Benam badsha”  that “aurat ki izat pe agar ek bar dag lag gaya to kabhi nahi dhul sakta hei” so what about the male? Isn’t they have any worry about their izzat? As well third gender is also find problem, they are marginalize, in tv serial Shakti stitvaki a female protagonist has humiliating by this word, “Kinnar ka koi ghar , koi mazhab nahi hota,” isn’t they are human? So like this the language of india is patriarchal or bias.

Conclusion:
     Indian culture is well propagated by means of the Indian films featured across different parts of the world. Indians are settled in different parts of the world and with their charm, Indian movies are also travelling across the globe.  

          There are many movies giving the special note of the Indian culture and its importance. The pride and honour of our culture has been well expressed by the various actors and actresses of the film industry. Media is the fastest means of communication and movies have a long term impact on people in comparison to any other form. With such a crucial role to play, Indian cinema has spread its charm worldwide.



The latest movies of the Indian film industry have definitely created a setback to the values of the Indian culture. The film industry has become more focussed towards attracting the young age group, with their silly tactics of featuring the romantic stories in an unedited manner. Some of the movies definitely are going much out of the values of Indian culture. It would be better if we can refine those movies as well to retain the charm of our culture and prestige forever. ol Language is also a part of culture and its also play a pivotal role in to shaping of society. Film, literature and culture are inter connected traits which is equally important in to the shaping of society and nation.
Work Citation:
; (sahi)
 (jaiduk)
(D'ALLANT)